Nearly a thousand suppliers left out of pocket from David Jonesโ collapse will be forced to wait until next year to find out how significant their losses will be as administrators seek a buyer to take on the 188-year-old retailer with debts expected to blow past the half-a-billion-dollar mark.
More than 500 suppliers who joined David Jonesโ first creditorsโ meeting via Zoom on Tuesday morning received little assurance they would get their money back, as administrators McGrathNicol revealed the department store owed $419 million to various parties when it collapsed.
This figure does not include potential claims for unpaid rent and additional expenses from landlords, and the significant cost of paying redundancies for thousands of staff who will lose their jobs as half the groupโs stores close. The employee payments will rank ahead of suppliersโ.
Suppliers are unlikely to find out how much of their debt they can recoup until mid to late January, after administrators have had time to shortlist and then negotiate with potential bidders for David Jones in December. Deadlines for expressions of interest were due last Friday afternoon.
Representatives for landlord Charter Hall and major brands including LโOrรฉal, Sheridan, Bonds, Dermalogica and Jurlique asked about their position in the pecking order of creditors, how to process refunds and whether they could retrieve their stock.
โWe need clear answers,โ said European fashion and footwear label director Rocco Mascitelli in the meeting. Receiver and manager FTI Consulting, in charge of David Jonesโ day-to-day business, was not responding to his queries about retrieving stock, he said.
โWe donโt seem to get any answers. So, although you guys [McGrathNicol] are not in charge of this process, weโre not getting any answers from FTI.โ
McGrathNicol partners Jason Preston, Shaun Fraser, Jacinta Nielsen and Matthew Hutton, who have been appointed voluntary administrators, are running the sale process. Overseeing day-to-day operations, including store closures, are FTI Consulting senior managing directors Christopher Hill, David McGrath and Joanne Dunn, who have been appointed as receivers and managers of the business by David Jones lender, Hilco
Fraser, McGrathNicolโs founding partner, said the firm would raise supplier concerns with FTI. โIt is too early to form a conclusive view on the potential returns to unsecured creditors,โ he said.
David Jonesโ $419 million debt is owed to a range of parties, including its private equity owner, its lender, nearly 1000 suppliers, and more than 6000 employees, McGrathNicol revealed.
The figure includes $180 million owed to 940 brands that have lodged debt claims, $11 million owed to 6242 workers, and $33 million owed to an estimated 800,000 gift card holders.
The biggest debts are owed to British distressed business lender Hilco ($115 million), followed by Sydney private equity firm Anchorage Capital ($80 million).
After Anchorage Capital purchased David Jones in December 2022, the department storeโs issues were โclearly a business model problemโ, said Fraser. Rent, wages and other costs grew, while foot traffic and shopper spending slowed, he said.
McGrathNicol will also examine whether Anchorage operated David Jones while it was insolvent.
David Jonesโ directors, who include CEO Erica Berchtold and Anchorage Capital executives Simon Woodhouse and Phillip Cave, have sought safe harbour protections to shield themselves from personal liability or penalties, the administrators confirmed, although they are not sure when they sought that protection.
The second creditorsโ meeting, in which creditors will be asked to approve any deal proposal, will be held no later than March 2027, the administrators said.
Redundancy packages are yet to be finalised as the receivers may announce more store closures. Affected workers can expect to be informed โin the coming daysโ, the administrators said.
Retail union SDA NSW secretary Bernie Smith said he was โvery disappointedโ that only 170 jobs were being redeployed from 1689 jobs set to go as a result of the closure of the 19 stores so far.
โWe see this as a missed opportunity both for the workers and also for the business to reset the service level they could provide that David Jones was once known for,โ he said.
Smith urged shoppers to be kind and compassionate to David Jones store workers going through a difficult time. โTake the time to thank them for the service they have given you and to your community.โ
The Business Briefing newsletter delivers major stories, exclusive coverage and expert opinion. Sign up to get it every weekday morning.