NAB has refused to pay staff for the full period it allegedly underpaid them, and has appointed embattled consultancy KPMG, which operates its whistleblower hotline, to also check its underpayment sums, leaving long-term employees furious.
Former staff members said they had complained about simple errors costing them pay as far back as 2004, but were brushed off by their managers, who insisted the bankโs maths was correct.
When the bank reported the issues to the federal pay regulator in 2019, it committed to repaying employees from 2012 onwards, prompting complaints to NABโs whistleblower hotline.
This masthead has confirmed KPMG never followed up with a staff member who raised concerns. Later, the firm was handed a contract by NAB to check its repayment sums for the years it had agreed to cover.
On Thursday last week, NAB formally agreed to pay $169 million to 65,999 current and former staff for lost wages, superannuation and interest between 2012 and this year.
Many were underpaid because of a basic error: the bankโs systems presumed a standard workweek was 40 hours when it was 38. That blunder, which the bank acknowledged in internal communications seen by this masthead, meant many part-time workers whose pay was set at a proportion of full-time hours were underpaid by more than 5 per cent every year.
For example, someone working 19 hours a week should have received half of a full-time wage. Instead, they received less.
Those issues, former staff said, date back to 2004, when a new computer system started handling staff pay. Pay statements seen by this masthead show employees were not being paid the correct percentage in the 2000s and were puzzled by the bankโs calculations.
But NAB is repaying staff only back to 2012. That is longer than the six years required under federal law, but leaves long-term staff to cope with the shortfall in eight yearsโ pay, superannuation, and interest.
One staff member, who had previously been rebuffed by NAB personnel in the early 2000s after querying pay rates, contacted the bankโs whistleblower service in 2021 on behalf of dozens of colleagues. It is called FairCall and operated by KPMG, the consulting firm that has been engulfed in its own whistleblower scandal since March this year.
Online, NAB describes FairCall as an โindependently monitored external hotline and reporting serviceโ.
In correspondence seen by this masthead, the staff member told FairCall that โas employees of NAB we all have to abide by the code of conductโ.
โWeโre not asking for anything more than to be treated fairly and put back in the position we should have been,โ the staff member said.
โNABโs lack of governance, including not checking the payroll systemโs accuracy when many of its staff questioned it, and colleagues not making the right decisions because theyโre not following the Code of Conduct, has resulted in many colleagues being treated unfairly.โ
The staff member noted that the bankโs code of conduct requires workers to abide by statements of high morals. โDo whatโs right, even when itโs hard,โ the bank instructs its people. It tells them to โโOwn Itโ when the right course of action isnโt clearโ. When thinking about a decision, staff should be guided by whether they would โproudly support this decision in publicโ, the bank says.
KPMG never responded to the NAB employeeโs query. Later, it won a contract to check that the bankโs repayment maths was correct.
Last year, the staff member wrote to NABโs chairman Philip Chronican to raise concerns about KPMGโs dual role.
โI have not received an explanation of how this conflict was managed, or why my complaint was disregarded,โ the staff member wrote. โThe absence of a response raises serious concerns that my complaint may have been deliberately buried or disregarded due to this conflict of interest.โ
NABโs HR boss Sarah White did not address questions about why the bank โ which reported more than $6 billion in profit last financial year โ has not voluntarily extended its repayment period back to the alleged start of the pay issues.
โWe take our payroll obligations extremely seriously as a basic element in employing people,โ White said in a statement. โWe sincerely apologise for these unintended errors and are working to resolve these as soon as we can.โ
The bank has not disputed that the pay issues began before 2012, and has privately said it cannot investigate the staff claims to go back further because it cannot find the necessary records.
White said the bank had been working with the Fair Work Ombudsman, which pursues underpayment cases, had already completed most of the repayments and would pay back any other people entitled to money.
As part of its legal agreement with the ombudsman this month, the bank agreed to make a $2 million contrition payment, which was a record but also only a tiny fraction of its annual profit.
It is common for underpayment issues to stretch beyond the six-year limitation period and many institutions do not repay staff more than they are legally required to.
A NAB spokesman said the bankโs FairCall service was only a reporting channel that relayed complaints to its internal service. โNAB is responsible for administering its whistleblower program and determining how disclosures are assessed or investigated,โ the spokesman said.
โ[NABโs internal] whistleblower program oversees matters and appoints investigators with the appropriate capability and independence, including considering and managing any potential conflicts.
โConsistent with our confidentiality obligations, we cannot comment on individual whistleblower matters.โ
In March, Labor Senator Deborah OโNeill revealed claims from a KPMG whistleblower that senior staff at the firm had taken confidential information from its clients and used it to attempt to win other work. Many of those claims have since been substantiated.
A KPMG spokesman said that โinformation received through FairCall remains confidential from the broader KPMG firmโ. โKPMG personnel undertaking any other services do not have access to FairCall complaints or related information,โ the spokesman said.
The Greensโ finance spokeswoman, Senator Barbara Pocock, said KPMGโs position โsmells like a conflict of interestโ.
โGiven all that we now know about KPMG, it is beyond belief that any company would outsource a whistleblower hotline to KPMG, especially when they are doing work in potential predictable conflict with the complaints they are dealing with,โ said Pocock, who has been a leading member of the parliamentary committee investigating the firm.
โWhistleblowers risk everything and must be protected, and itโs clear KPMG cannot be trusted on this.โ
In the bankโs reply to the staff member on Chronicanโs behalf, an executive from NAB said that it had looked into the concerns raised via KPMG in 2021 and dismissed them, in part because the employee had chosen to remain anonymous, and therefore it was harder to follow up.
The repayment period was a โmanagement decision and there was no evidence of wrongdoingโ, NAB said.
But it apologised for failing to relay that response back to the staff member, blaming a โcommunication issueโ.
A spokesman for the Fair Work Ombudsman said that while the law limited it to recovering six years of lost wages in court, NAB had agreed to go beyond that, back to 2012, in its enforceable agreement with the regulator.
โWhilst the scale of the non-compliance in the NAB matter is disappointing, we do not believe the contraventions were committed deliberately, and NAB has co-operated fully in rectifying the underpayments and overhauling its governance and compliance systems to ensure it complies in future,โ the spokesman said. He said NABโs repayment methodology favoured staff and paid a record contrition payment. โWe have no further comment,โ he said.
The Business Briefing newsletter delivers major stories, exclusive coverage and expert opinion. Sign up to get it every weekday morning.