In the final interview that secured his appointment as coach of the Melbourne Football Club in late 1997, Neale Daniher faced a pointed question from the Demons’ then president and financial white knight Joseph Gutnick.
“What will you do when we lose five games in a row?,” asked Gutnick, who had just removed Daniher’s avuncular predecessor Neil Balme.
“Don’t worry about me, Joe,” Daniher replied. “What will you do?”
Neale Daniher was not averse to concise quips or epigrams – both irreverent and meaning-of-life serious.
One Daniher-ism was deployed by the Demons in their triumphant 2021 grand final in Perth, adorning the team’s rooms before the game and cited by skipper Max Gawn as a catalyst for their turnaround.
“When it’s all said and done, more is said than done,” it read.
Daniher is one of few in Australian public life whose death could draw tributes from the prime minister, from the senior coach of the past two AFL premierships (close mate and colleague Chris Fagan) and from those in the fight against motor neurone disease that made him a transcendent national figure and the 2025 Australian of the Year.
Daniher, of course, tenaciously fought this most pernicious of diseases both physically and as a public advocate – and did so without any hint of the self-pity that anyone would be entitled to feel.
Daniher’s public life had three distinct phases.
Act One was as a prospective champion, the second Daniher brother from the renowned Riverina clan – a brilliant, smooth halfback flanker who, in his decorated teammate Tim Watson’s description, “stepped straight out of Assumption College on to the Essendon halfback line.”
“I wouldn’t be doing what I’m doing if it wasn’t for him. He plucked me from nowhere … It was a pretty bold decision … He helped me believe in myself as a coach.”
Chris Fagan
Daniher would play 66 consecutive games for the Bombers, most of them alongside his accomplished brother Terry, before a succession of knee injuries, initially from the final home and away round of 1981, derailed a career on the cusp of superstardom.
Then, Neale was considered the pick of the Danihers. He had been the steak knives in the Swans’ (then South Melbourne) disastrous trade that swapped star forward Terry for centreman Neville Fields.
Watson did not think comparisons with Carlton’s silent defender Bruce Doull were unreasonable, Neale having taken Essendon’s best and fairest in ’81, famously snatching a nigh-unwinnable game at Princes Park for the Dons when shifted forward late with nerveless goals at the 30 and 31-minute marks.
Watson said Daniher, appointed captain in 1982 when bedevilled with knee issues that would plague him for years, was a serious player with a single-minded approach, even though “he was a Daniher and liked a beer” and a joke. “Once he decided he was going to do something, he did it.”
This resolution would serve him – and the MND cause – well.
Part Two of this Shakespearean drama was his celebrated coaching/football operative career, the largest share of which was his near-decade as coach of the Demons, whom he led to finals series in six out of ten years, despite ramshackle facilities at their Junction Oval base and only relatively modest talent on their playing list.
One of Daniher’s closest friends, ex-Melbourne vice president and Fight MND founding chairman Bill Guest recalled that the Junction Oval spread had “the roof collapsing and rats running around.”
Guest said “integrity and honesty” were Daniher’s abiding traits in coaching the Demons, who made the 2000 grand final and were crushed by Essendon, whom he also served as Kevin Sheedy’s assistant.
“He would never bullshit a player or anything – including if they were no good,” said Guest, who had seen Daniher last Thursday, and reckoned it a blessing that he passed away at his Canterbury home.
To this journalist, Neale could come across as somewhat taciturn, as a forthright man from Ungarie with a hard edge who did not manipulate either words or players.
But he was intelligent – Melbourne’s then chief executive (and later 2000s) Cameron Schwab had cited Daniher’s intellect as a key factor in his hiring from Fremantle (assistant coach to Gerard Neesham). His straight-talk and underlying care imbued him with authority and found receptive audiences from his senior players such as David Neitz, David Schwarz, Adem Yze, James McDonald and Brad Green.
Fagan had been teary on Monday upon hearing that his mate had finally departed, after a dozen or so years fending off MND and losing capacities. “We were the same age, and he was like my big brother,” the Brisbane Lions coach told this masthead.
Daniher managed only one solitary game with all three brothers (Terry, Anthony and Chris) in 1990 at the instigation of Sheedy.
Fagan felt he owed his career as an AFL coach to Daniher, who hired the Tasmanian from relative obscurity and made him his right hand for the entirety of Neale’s stint at Melbourne. “I wouldn’t be doing what I’m doing if it wasn’t for him. He plucked me from nowhere…it was a pretty bold decision.”
Fagan concurred with the view that Daniher was unfailingly honest, adding on a personal level: “He helped me believe in myself as a coach.”
This Second Act of Daniher’s public life saw a brief segue as CEO of the AFL Coaches’ Association, before he took on the challenge of helping John Worsfold renew the morale and fibre of a fallen West Coast team as the club’s football boss.
Sheedy had longed – and had pushed – for Daniher to succeed him as senior coach in 2007. It was, as Guest recalled, a job that Daniher felt he was likely to land.
The Essendon hierarchy, however, was adamant about turning a page on the Sheedy era, and spurned both Daniher and a less experienced version of Damien Hardwick, for ex-Tiger Matthew Knights, who would be the first of several Bomber coaches to swiftly disappear down the Windy Hill or Tullamarine trap door.
The prodigal homecoming never happened. Nor did another club hire Daniher as senior coach, despite his impressive record in trying circumstances at Melbourne. Fagan long maintained that his friend should have coached again.
“On reflection, it would have been a great appointment,” said Watson of Daniher’s failure to return to Essendon.
MND intervened in 2013, and it was in Act Three of Daniher’s life that he found both tragedy and the most uplifting of storylines, leading, as it did, to the Big Freeze at the MCG on the King’s Birthday, and a national spotlight on the disease that was slowly taking him down.
So, in addition to a state funeral, when the Demons play Collingwood on June 8, the 90,000 or so who fill the MCG in blue beanies – and the many more watching celebrities slide for MND – will underscore just what the life of Neale Daniher meant.
Keep up to date with the best AFL coverage in the country. Sign up for the Real Footy newsletter
Jake Niall is a Walkley award-winning sports journalist and chief AFL writer for The Age.Connect via X or email.
