1. Carter Gordon a mixed bag in stifled attack
The Wallabies’ defensive attitude was much-improved in their dour 15-12 loss to Scotland in Edinburgh, but the attack left a lot to be desired as they lost the aerial battle and were comprehensively beaten at the breakdown.
Carter Gordon was a mixed bag at No.10. He created space nicely for Harry Potter’s try in the first half, but when the Wallabies needed to strike just before halftime – having turned down three points – there was a communication breakdown as he lofted a crossfield kick to no one, with Max Jorgensen clearly expecting the ball to be kept in hand.
There is very little happening around the ruck for the Wallabies on attack for the Wallabies – Tate McDermott changed the picture when he was introduced very late – and it is letting teams pick off the Wallabies wider out. Len Ikitau and Joseph-Aukuso Suaalii were virtually anonymous in midfield, and the current pile-on on top of Suaalii misses the point a little: the Wallabies just aren’t creating a lot as an entire backline.
The issue was compounded by Scotland’s tenacity at the breakdown. They made a mess of Wallabies ball all afternoon.
2. Gordon’s shift to No.12 showed promise
Ben Donaldson finished the game at No.10 and showed some nice touches, and his introduction pushed Gordon out one with Suaalii at centre (Ikitau was somewhat surprisingly the man who made way for Donaldson). The new configuration didn’t get much time together and was hard to fully assess, but it did at least appear to give the Wallabies more width on attack.
Former Wallabies coach Ewen McKenzie has been banging the drum for Gordon at No.12 for years, and those in that camp could argue that there was enough evidence to give it more time in the future. Gordon’s great strength is his ability to take the ball to the line before passing, and there is clearly an argument for seeing more of him there as the game opens up.
But, oddly enough, the Test also showed the irreplaceable value of a line-bending No.12. Scotland lost captain Sione Tuipulotu just before kick-off, which compromised their entire attacking shape. Without Tuipulotu’s ability to smash over the gainline, Scotland maestro Finn Russell found himself running sideways on attack and couldn’t unleash his usual array of tricks.
3. Former Waratah still going strong for Scotland
Jack Dempsey’s footwork at the line was a feature for Scotland as he led the ball-carrying statistics in the Test, with 17. It also contrasted with the impact Rob Valetini and Harry Wilson had on the Test, with Valetini only managing seven metres from seven carries and Wilson making less than that from five carries.
The juice was taken out of the Wallabies’ back-rowers by the sheer volume of tackles they were forced to make, with Wilson and Fraser McReight accounting for more than 50 between them. The Wallabies don’t look as visibly fatigued as they were this time last year, but there is no doubt the energy levels have looked a bit depleted in recent weeks.
The Six Nations sides are so effective and hard-working at the breakdown. It was definitely the big lost battleground for the Wallabies in Edinburgh, because their lineout and scrum managed to exert a bit of pressure on the Scots.
4. Welsh warning for Wallabies
Wales’ defence during the last 20 minutes of their famous 35-28 win against the All Blacks was remarkable, but it almost disguised how good they were on attack at the start of the first half and during the same period in the second spell. Playing with tempo and width, the Welsh found lots of space on the edges in a manner that could cause issues for the Wallabies next weekend.
But the undoubted star was halfback Tomos Williams. He was the architect of Wales’ varied attacking play and frequently invited ball runners to hit the line with his clever play around the ruck. The Test in Cardiff this weekend suddenly looks a lot more challenging for the Wallabies than it did a week ago.
5. Paris and Cardiff show Test rugby is without peer
Only very tough judges could fail to have be moved by the French and Welsh victories against the Springboks and All Blacks, respectively. Not only were they upsets – the latter a massive shock – but they again showed the international game is in rude health.
The Nations Championship concept will take time to take hold, and even that is not guaranteed in the long term, but the participating countries are clearly putting huge value in it and the race for the top spot on the hemisphere ladders is going down to the wire.
But Tests remain standalone occasions capable of lifting a nation’s mood on one afternoon. The Welsh were magnificent against the All Blacks, and that victory that will lift the clouds that have been hanging over the Welsh game for years.
News, results and expert analysis from the weekend of sport sent every Friday. Sign up for our Sport newsletter.