In 2022, the state of Gujarat suddenly granted remission of sentence to the eleven men, meaning that it pardoned their remaining sentences and they were released. The Sentencing Review Board had ten government appointees, whose politics were conveniently aligned with that of the convicts. Their release was a political event — they were garlanded when they came out of prison. Bilkis left her residence in fear and trauma.
The politics of hate that was acted out on her body has not abated. It has only become more centrestage. The convicts have shown no remorse nor been given a reason to introspect. They have instead been honoured for their role in the violence.
In 2022, the Supreme Court intervened and ruled that the state of Gujarat had no power to grant remissions since the case had been tried in Maharashtra. The convicts had to return to jail. Now two of them have been granted a suspension of sentence by the Supreme Court, since their appeals are pending and because they have ‘served a long sentence already’.
Bilkis was not given notice nor heard before this order was passed. Had she been present, she may have reiterated that she feels intimidated by their physical presence and by the fact that their hateful violent act is celebrated as a political victory. In fact, such behaviour by someone released on bail would ordinarily result in cancellation of bail. But not so for Bilkis’s attackers.
Bilkis’s case could have been framed as an act of terror. In that moment it was meant to terrorise an entire community.
Each felicitation of the perpetrators is a reiteration of that act of terror. The prosecution could at least have invoked special laws. In the event, the eleven men were tried and convicted for being part of an unlawful assembly that committed rapes and murders. The framing of a criminal case is a very political act.
The law believes it acts in silos: each case is judged on its own merits, as a complete whole. But somehow, when broader patterns are considered across cases, the arc of justice seems to tilt away from the marginals.
Shahrukh Alam is a constitutional lawyer and human rights activist. More of her writing here