The NRL avoided its own โGeelong momentโ after the Canberra Raiders refused to let Corey Harawira-Naera sign a waiver that would have seen him assume all responsibility for future on-field injuries.
The AFL was earlier this month rocked by reports that Geelong and Jake Kolodjashnij, a player with a history of concussive incidents, signed a legal waiver that protected the club as part of Kolodjashnijโs continued employment.
The so-called liability waiver was never registered by the AFL.
Now this masthead can reveal a similar situation had almost unfolded in rugby league when Harawira-Naera was desperate to resume playing, despite suffering a seizure during a game in 2023.
Harawira-Naera underwent a series of tests and was eventually fitted with an implantable cardioverter-defibrillator (ICD) โ a small, battery-operated device implanted under the skin in the armpit to monitor and treat life-threatening heart arrhythmias.
The New Zealand international was cleared to resume training by cardiologists, but when the Raiders refused to entertain any playing comeback in the middle of 2024, Harawira-Naera allegedly told the club he was happy to sign a waiver, which was quickly rejected.
โThat could have been our โGeelong momentโ,โ Raiders chief executive Don Furner said on Sunday.
โWe met with Corey and even had a Zoom call with one of his cardiologists in Melbourne, but we were never going to take the risk. We told Corey and his management that.
โWe were happy for Corey to continue working at the club, and paid out the remainder of his playing contract.
โAfter doing all that, and assuring them we werenโt prepared to put Coreyโs life at risk, his management said, โCorey is happy to sign a waiverโ.
โBut we never entertained it. Iโm no solicitor, but I know you couldnโt waive away your duty of care to an employee. These waivers wouldnโt have held up legally anywhere if a tragedy happened.
โHe wanted to keep playing footy. At the end of the day, we had to protect Corey from himself.
โI read an article about the Geelong situation and how the most difficult road for the club would have been sitting the player down and urging him to retire. Thatโs what we did with Corey.
โWe never kept our dealings with Corey a secret, and we were in regular contact with the NRL and their chief medical officer.โ
โAt the end of the day, we had to protect Corey from himself.โ
Raiders CEO Don Furner
Furner, the gameโs longest-serving NRL club CEO, said he expected more players to offer to sign waivers in the future, especially when it came to concussion, and it was important the game had clear policies and return-to-play protocols.
โIโll actually raise this point the next time the clubs get together,โ Furner said.
โI do think the Geelong incident could lead to similar dilemmas in our game, with players desperate to keep playing, even if it means going against medical advice.
โThey might be tempted to sign waivers or legal documents if it means they prolong their careers, especially with how much money can be made in the game now.โ
Sources with knowledge of the Harawira-Naera situation not authorised to speak publicly said the waiver was raised with the NRL integrity unit, rather than the Raiders, in relation to a potential return with a rival club, and fulfilling the insurance requirements of a pre-existing condition.
Harawira-Naera told this masthead in an interview in May last year, after confirming there were no medical, legal or regulatory impediments to an NRL return: โEveryone was telling me to give up because it was so unprecedented and no one has been through something like this before in rugby league, [but] I didnโt feel content giving up without trying.
โIโve just got to get myself in peak fitness and buy into a teamโs protocols or values, watching games and how I can contribute to a team. Iโve still got confidence in myself.
โIโve just got to get to a place that will allow me to get back to my best and have enough time to do that.โ
The Cats last week received a โplease explainโ from the AFL over their deal with Kolodjashnij, with coach Chris Scott yet to be informed about when the 30-year-old will be cleared to resume playing.
From our partners
About the Author
